By In this article, we will compare the Ather 450X and Ather 450S electric scooters. We’ll look at their prices, range, performance, and features to help you decide which one is better for you. Both models have their strengths and weaknesses, so understanding these differences is key to making an informed choice.
Key Takeaways
-
The Ather 450S is more affordable than the 450X, making it a budget-friendly option.
-
Both scooters have similar charging times, around 8.36 hours.
-
The Ather 450S offers a slightly longer range of 115 km compared to the 450X’s 111 km.
-
The 450X has a more powerful motor, giving it a performance edge.
-
Both models come with modern features like digital displays and smartphone connectivity.
Price Comparison
Ex-Showroom Prices
When we look at the ex-showroom prices, the Ather 450S is the more affordable option, starting at around ₹1.17 lakh. In contrast, the Ather 450X comes in at a higher price, starting at approximately ₹1.42 lakh. This makes the 450S a great choice for those on a budget.
On-Road Prices
The on-road prices reflect the total cost after including registration, insurance, and other fees. For the Ather 450S, the on-road price can reach up to ₹1.30 lakh, while the Ather 450X can go up to ₹1.77 lakh. This difference is significant and can influence our decision.
Cost of Ownership
When considering the cost of ownership, we should think about factors like maintenance, insurance, and charging costs. Here’s a quick breakdown:
-
Ather 450S: Lower maintenance costs and better efficiency can lead to savings over time.
-
Ather 450X: While it has higher initial costs, its performance may justify the investment for some users.
In summary, while the Ather 450S is cheaper upfront, the Ather 450X offers features that might appeal to those looking for more performance. We need to weigh our options carefully based on our budget and needs.
Range and Charging Time
Range Per Charge
When we look at the range of the Ather 450X and 450S, we see some interesting differences. The Ather 450X offers a range of up to 115 km per charge, while the 450S provides a slightly lower range of 111 km. This means that for daily commutes, both models can handle typical city travel without needing frequent recharges.
Charging Time
Charging time is crucial for electric vehicles. Both models take about 8.36 hours to charge fully from a standard outlet. However, if we use a fast charger, we can charge them to 80% in just about 6.36 hours. This flexibility allows us to plan our charging around our daily routines.
Charging Options
We have several options for charging these bikes:
-
Home Charging: Plug into a regular 5A socket.
-
Fast Charging: Use a 15A socket for quicker charging.
-
Portable Charger: Both models come with a portable charger, making it easy to charge on the go.
In summary, both the Ather 450X and 450S provide decent ranges and flexible charging options, making them suitable for urban commuting.
Performance Metrics
Motor Power
Both the Ather 450X and 450S come equipped with powerful motors. The 450X boasts a motor power of 6.4 kW, while the 450S has a slightly lower power of 5.4 kW. This difference can impact how quickly each model accelerates and performs under various conditions.
Top Speed
When it comes to speed, both models can reach a top speed of 90 km/h. This makes them suitable for city commuting and occasional highway rides.
Acceleration
In terms of acceleration, the 450X is designed to offer a more responsive ride, allowing it to reach higher speeds more quickly. The 450S, while still capable, may feel a bit slower in comparison.
Overall, both models provide a thrilling ride, but the 450X stands out with its enhanced motor power and quicker acceleration.
-
Braking Performance: Both models feature effective braking systems, ensuring safety during sudden stops.
-
Riding Modes: Each bike offers multiple riding modes, allowing us to choose between performance and efficiency based on our needs.
Design and Build Quality
Frame and Materials
Both the Ather 450X and 450S feature a precision machined hybrid chassis that gives them a sturdy feel. This design not only enhances the overall strength but also contributes to a lightweight structure, making it easier to handle. The materials used are high-quality, ensuring durability and longevity.
Color Options
When it comes to aesthetics, we have a variety of color options available for both models. The 450X comes in Salt Green, Cosmic Black, and Space Grey, while the 450S offers True Red, Still White, and Lunar Grey. These vibrant colors add a personal touch to each scooter, appealing to different tastes.
Build Quality
In our experience, the build quality of both models is impressive. The 450X is known for its robust construction, while the 450S also feels well-made. Both scooters are designed to withstand daily wear and tear, making them reliable choices for urban commuting.
Overall, the design and build quality of the Ather 450X and 450S reflect a commitment to excellence, ensuring that riders enjoy both style and substance.
Features and Technology
Instrument Console
The Ather 450X and 450S come with a high-tech instrument console that enhances the riding experience. Both models feature a digital display that shows important information like speed, battery level, and trip details. The 450X has a touch screen, making it easier to navigate through options.
Connectivity Features
Both models are equipped with smart connectivity features. They allow us to connect our smartphones for:
-
Call and SMS alerts
-
Navigation assistance
-
Music control
-
Over-the-air (OTA) updates
Safety Features
Safety is a priority in both models. They include:
-
Anti-theft alarm
-
Regenerative braking
-
Hill assist
-
Combined braking system for better control
In our experience, these features not only enhance safety but also make riding more enjoyable.
Overall, the Ather 450X and 450S are packed with modern features that cater to tech-savvy riders, ensuring a safe and connected ride.
Comfort and Convenience
Seating Comfort
When we think about comfort, the seating plays a huge role. Both the Ather 450X and 450S offer a comfortable ride, but we noticed some differences. The seat height is set at 780 mm, making it accessible for most riders. However, neither model has a pillion backrest, which might be a downside for those who often ride with a passenger.
Storage Options
Storage is essential for daily use. Both models come with under-seat storage of 22 liters, which is quite handy for carrying essentials. Unfortunately, there is no front storage box available in either model.
Ride Quality
The ride quality is generally smooth, but we found that the 450X feels a bit firmer compared to the 450S. This might be something to consider if we prefer a softer ride.
Overall, both models provide decent comfort and convenience, but the choice may depend on our personal preferences regarding ride quality and storage needs.
User Reviews and Ratings
Overall Ratings
When we look at the user ratings for the Ather 450X and 450S, we see some interesting feedback:
-
Ather 450X: 4.5/5 from 43 ratings
-
Ather 450S: 4.1/5 from 235 ratings
Common Praises
Many users have shared their positive experiences:
-
Performance: Both models are praised for their smooth rides and quick acceleration.
-
Design: The sleek and modern look of the scooters stands out on the road.
-
Features: Users appreciate the advanced technology, including the mobile app connectivity and LED lighting.
Common Complaints
However, there are some areas where users feel improvements are needed:
-
Storage Space: Some riders find the under-seat storage a bit cramped, especially in the 450S.
-
Ride Quality: A few users mentioned that the ride can feel firm, particularly on rough roads.
Overall, the feedback shows that while both models have their strengths, there are also areas for improvement. We can see that the Ather scooters are making a mark in the electric vehicle market, but user experiences vary based on personal preferences.
Pros and Cons
Advantages of Ather 450X
-
Lightweight and easy to maneuver, making it perfect for city rides.
-
The estimated range is very accurate, giving us confidence in our travels.
-
Warp mode offers a thrilling experience, making rides fun and exciting.
Advantages of Ather 450S
-
The build quality feels solid, ensuring durability over time.
-
Removable batteries are a significant advantage, allowing for easy charging.
-
It comes packed with features, including a removable rear seat, enhancing convenience.
Disadvantages of Both Models
-
The Ather 450X has limited underseat storage, especially with the portable charger taking up space.
-
The ride quality can feel a bit firm, which might not be comfortable for everyone.
-
The Ather 450S has a cramped riding posture, which may not suit taller riders.
In summary, both models have their strengths and weaknesses. While the Ather 450X excels in performance and handling, the 450S offers better convenience with its removable batteries. Choosing between them depends on our specific needs and preferences.
Final Thoughts
In the end, choosing between the Ather 450X and the Ather 450S comes down to what you need. The 450S offers a longer range of 115 km, making it great for longer rides. On the other hand, the 450X has a bit more power and features, but its range is slightly less at 111 km. Both scooters have similar charging times and top speeds. If you want a more budget-friendly option, the 450S is the way to go. But if you prefer extra features and power, then the 450X might be better for you. Think about your riding style and needs before making a choice.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the price difference between the Ather 450X and 450S?
The Ather 450S is cheaper than the Ather 450X by about ₹25,157.
Which scooter has a longer range?
The Ather 450S can go up to 115 km on a single charge, while the Ather 450X has a range of 111 km.
How long does it take to charge both scooters?
Both the Ather 450X and 450S take about 8.36 hours to fully charge.
What is the top speed of these scooters?
Both the Ather 450X and 450S can reach a top speed of 90 km/h.
Are there different color options available for these models?
Yes, the Ather 450S comes in 4 colors, while the Ather 450X is available in 6 colors.
How do users rate the Ather 450X and 450S?
The Ather 450S has an average rating of 4.5 out of 5, whereas the Ather 450X has a rating of 4.1 out of 5.