In the world of electric scooters, two names stand out: Ather 450X and Simple Energy One. Both offer unique designs, impressive features, and solid performance. This article will dive into how they compare across various aspects, helping you decide which one might be the better fit for your needs.

Key Takeaways

• The Ather 450X has a sleek, sporty design, while the Simple Energy One offers a bulkier but well-proportioned look.
• In terms of range, the Simple Energy One leads with 212 km, compared to Ather’s 146 km.
• Acceleration is quicker on the Simple Energy One, reaching 40 km/h in just 2.7 seconds, versus 3.3 seconds for the Ather.
• Both scooters come with modern features, but the Ather’s user interface is noted for being particularly user-friendly.
• Pricing for both scooters is competitive, making them appealing options for electric scooter buyers.

Design and Aesthetics

Visual Appeal of Ather 450X

The Ather 450X stands out with its sleek and modern design. Its sharp lines and compact form make it look stylish and appealing. The unique headlamp design adds a touch of elegance, making it a head-turner on the streets.

Visual Appeal of Simple Energy One

In contrast, the Simple Energy One adopts a more aggressive styling. With bold character lines and a sporty stance, it aims to attract younger riders. The dual-tone finish enhances its visual appeal, making it look both modern and desirable.

Build Quality and Materials

Both scooters are built with quality materials, but there are some differences. The Ather 450X feels more premium with its solid build, while the Simple Energy One has some fit and finish issues that need addressing. However, the Simple Energy team assures us that these will be improved in the final production models.

Colour Options and Customization

When it comes to colour choices, both scooters offer a variety of options. The Ather 450X comes in colours like black, green, and red, while the Simple Energy One offers shades like Namma Red and Azure Blue. Customization options are also available, allowing riders to personalize their scooters to match their style.

In the world of electric scooters, design plays a crucial role in attracting buyers. A well-designed scooter not only looks good but also enhances the overall riding experience.

Battery and Range

Battery Specifications of Ather 450X

The Ather 450X is equipped with a powerful battery that offers impressive performance. It features a 2.9 kWh lithium-ion battery, which provides a decent range for daily commuting. With a range of up to 146 km on a single charge, it is designed for urban riders. The charging time is approximately 5-6 hours using a standard home charger.

Battery Specifications of Simple Energy One

On the other hand, the Simple Energy One boasts a larger battery capacity of 5 kWh. This allows it to achieve a remarkable range of up to 212 km, making it a strong contender for longer rides. The charging time is around 4 hours for a full charge, and it also supports fast charging, which is a great convenience for users.

Range Comparison

When we compare the two, the Simple Energy One clearly stands out with its longer range. Here’s a quick summary:

• Ather 450X: Up to 146 km
• Simple Energy One: Up to 212 km

This difference can be crucial for those who need to travel longer distances without frequent charging.

Charging Time and Convenience

Both scooters offer reasonable charging times, but the Simple Energy One has the edge with its fast charging capabilities. Here’s a breakdown:

• Ather 450X: 5-6 hours (standard charger)
• Simple Energy One: 4 hours (standard charger) and supports fast charging
• In conclusion, while both scooters have their strengths, the Simple Energy One offers a better range and faster charging options, making it a more appealing choice for many riders.

Performance and Speed

Acceleration and Top Speed

Both the Ather 450X and Simple Energy One offer impressive acceleration. The Ather 450X can go from 0 to 40 km/h in just 3.3 seconds, showcasing its powerful 6.4 kW motor. On the other hand, the Simple Energy One claims a similar feat, reaching 0 to 40 km/h in about 2.77 seconds. This rapid acceleration makes both scooters thrilling to ride.

Motor Power and Efficiency

When it comes to motor power, the Ather 450X delivers 6,000 Watts, while the Simple Energy One provides 7,000 Watts. This difference in power can affect how each scooter performs under various conditions. The efficiency of these motors is crucial for maximizing range and performance, ensuring that riders can enjoy longer journeys without frequent charging.

Ride Modes and Their Impact

Both scooters come with multiple ride modes:

• Ather 450X: Eco, Ride, and Sport modes.
• Simple Energy One: Eco, Ride, Dash, and Sonic modes.

Each mode adjusts the power output and speed, allowing riders to choose between efficiency and performance based on their needs. For instance, the Eco mode prioritizes range, while the Sonic mode unleashes maximum power for an exhilarating ride.

Real-World Performance

In real-world conditions, both scooters perform admirably. The Ather 450X offers a certified range of about 150 km, while the Simple Energy One boasts a range of 236 km in Eco mode. This means that for daily commutes, both scooters can handle the distance with ease.

In our experience, the performance of these electric scooters is not just about numbers; it’s about how they feel on the road. Both the Ather 450X and Simple Energy One provide a smooth and enjoyable ride, making them great choices for urban commuting.

Features and Technology

Dashboard and Instrument Console

Both the Ather 450X and Simple Energy One come equipped with a digital dashboard that provides essential information at a glance. The Ather 450X features a touch screen display, making it easy to navigate through various options. In contrast, the Simple Energy One also offers a digital console but lacks the touch functionality.

Connectivity Features

We appreciate the connectivity options available in both scooters. The Ather 450X supports mobile app connectivity, allowing us to monitor battery status and locate nearby charging stations. Similarly, the Simple Energy One also offers mobile app features, enhancing the overall user experience.

Safety and Assistance Features

Safety is a priority for both models. The Ather 450X includes features like geo-fencing and a stand alarm, which help keep the scooter secure. The Simple Energy One also provides essential safety features, ensuring a safe ride.

Lighting and Visibility

When it comes to lighting, both scooters are equipped with LED headlights and daytime running lights (DRLs). This ensures better visibility during night rides. The Ather 450X also includes a unique feature of ambient lighting, which adds to its modern appeal.

In summary, both scooters offer a range of features that cater to tech-savvy riders. While the Ather 450X leans towards more advanced technology, the Simple Energy One provides a solid set of features that meet the needs of everyday users.

Ride and Handling

Suspension Setup

When we think about how a scooter feels on the road, the suspension plays a big role. The Ather 450X has a telescopic front fork and a mono-shock rear suspension. This setup helps in absorbing bumps and gives us a smoother ride. On the other hand, the Simple Energy One also features a similar suspension design, which means both scooters are built to handle rough roads well.

Braking System

Braking is crucial for safety. Both scooters come with a disc braking system, which provides better stopping power compared to drum brakes. The Ather 450X has a combined braking system (CBS) that helps distribute braking force evenly. The Simple Energy One also offers a reliable braking system, ensuring we can stop quickly when needed.

Riding Comfort

Comfort is key when we ride for long distances. Both scooters have well-padded seats and ergonomic designs. Here’s what we noticed:

• Ather 450X: The seat height is 796 mm, making it easy for most riders to reach the ground.
• Simple Energy One: It also offers a comfortable seat height, but some riders feel it could be a bit more spacious.

Handling in Different Conditions

When it comes to handling, both scooters perform well in city traffic and on highways. However, we found that:

• The Ather 450X feels more agile in tight spaces.
• The Simple Energy One offers stability at higher speeds.

In our experience, both scooters provide a good balance of comfort and handling, making them suitable for daily commutes and longer rides.

Pricing and Value for Money

Ex-Showroom Prices

When we look at the prices of the Ather 450X and Simple Energy One, we see a significant difference. The Ather 450X starts at around ₹1,38,000, while the Simple Energy One is priced at approximately ₹1,78,021. This makes the Ather 450X a more budget-friendly option for many buyers.

Cost of Ownership

Owning an electric scooter comes with its own set of costs. Here are some factors to consider:

• Charging Costs: The average cost to fully charge the Ather 450X is about ₹30, while the Simple Energy One costs around ₹25.
• Maintenance: Electric scooters generally have lower maintenance costs compared to petrol scooters, as they have fewer moving parts.
• Insurance: Both scooters have similar insurance costs, which can vary based on the rider’s profile.

Subsidies and Incentives

In India, the government offers various subsidies for electric vehicles. This can significantly reduce the overall cost. For instance, buyers can benefit from:

• FAME II scheme, which provides incentives for electric two-wheelers.
• State-specific subsidies that can further lower the price.

Value Proposition

While the Ather 450X is cheaper, some users feel that the Simple Energy One offers better features. However, many reviews suggest that the Ather 450X provides better value for money due to its performance and reliability.

In the end, choosing between these two scooters depends on our budget and what features we prioritize. Both have their strengths, but we must weigh them against our needs.

User Reviews and Feedback

Customer Satisfaction

In our exploration of user feedback, we find a mix of opinions about both the Ather 450X and the Simple Energy One. Many riders appreciate the performance and design of these scooters, but there are also significant concerns regarding customer service and reliability. Overall, satisfaction levels vary widely among users.

Common Complaints

Some common issues reported by users include:

• Poor customer service: Many users have expressed frustration with the lack of timely responses from customer support.
• Service delays: Riders have noted that getting their scooters serviced can take longer than expected, sometimes up to several days.
• Performance issues: Some users have experienced sudden drops in power while riding, which can be alarming.

Expert Opinions

Experts generally agree that while both scooters have their strengths, they also have areas needing improvement. The Ather 450X is often praised for its design and technology, while the Simple Energy One is noted for its affordability but criticised for its service experience.

Market Reception

The market reception for both scooters has been mixed. While some users rave about their features and performance, others caution potential buyers to consider the service and support aspects before making a purchase.

“Choosing an electric scooter is not just about the ride; it’s also about the support you receive afterwards. Make sure to weigh all factors before deciding.”

Final Thoughts

In the end, choosing between the Ather 450X and the Simple Energy One comes down to what you need in an electric scooter. The Ather 450X has a sleek design and is known for its user-friendly features, making it a great choice for many riders. On the other hand, the Simple Energy One offers impressive speed and a longer range, which might appeal to those looking for more power. Both scooters have their strengths and weaknesses, so it’s important to think about what matters most to you. As the electric scooter market grows, both brands are pushing each other to improve, which is good news for customers. Ultimately, the best way to decide is to test ride both and see which one feels right for you.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the top speed of the Ather 450X?

The Ather 450X can reach a top speed of 90 km/h.

How long does it take to charge the Simple Energy One?

The Simple Energy One takes about 4 hours to charge fully.

What is the range of the Ather 450X on a single charge?

The Ather 450X has a certified range of 146 km.

Does the Simple Energy One have removable batteries?

Yes, the Simple Energy One features a hybrid battery setup with a removable battery.

How fast can the Simple Energy One accelerate?

The Simple Energy One can go from 0 to 40 km/h in just 2.7 seconds.

What kind of features does the Ather 450X offer?

The Ather 450X includes a large TFT screen, smartphone connectivity, and various ride modes.